↓ Skip to main content

Nov 17 2026 Board Meeting Recap

·755 words·4 mins
Prescott Balch
Author
Prescott Balch
Disclaimer: the opinions expressed in these posts are my own and are not to be construed as official opinions of the village. Please see https://caledonia-wi.gov/ for official communications.

Board Meeting
#

We got to conclusion on the self-storage proposal on Frontage Rd and 7-Mile Rd. I think we achieved the goal of making everyone moderately unhappy. This one was the toughest issue yet in my tenure on the board, requiring balancing resident impact, land use rights, and state and local law. Thanks to everyone for being patient. The final conditional use permit sets out terms that reduce impact on the neighborhood adjacent to the property while also allowing the property owner to build. And maybe as importantly, we learned something about how decisions we make about land use can impact residents. We should probably try to find and fix more of these problems before we have another one of these challenges.

We agreed with the Plan Commission proposal to reject the request to operate a “low-impact vehicle sales business” in the StorageShopUSA business condominiums. I voted Yes (to approve) in Plan Commission and Yes (to reject) in the Board meeting. Explaining my change of vote: between Plan Commission and the Board meeting, we found that the Building, Site, and Operation Plan (BSO) that was originally approved by the board precluded automotive businesses and retail businesses. At Plan Commission, it was represented that only the condominium rules prevented that, and I didn’t believe it was the Village’s place to enforce condo rules. When the BSO was presented with its restrictions, I felt obligated to enforce its terms. Thus the flip-flop.

Then, as expected, everything else on the agenda was approved without controversy: trailer business along the highway, plat extensions, 140-sq-foot shed (again, if the applicant is reading this, I’m sorry we made you go through all that!), traffic studies, some bills.

That part of the meeting lasted 1 hour, not bad considering the length of the agenda and the meaty topics at the start.

Committee of the Whole
#

This one lasted an hour as well and was a tad frustrating, but hey, sometimes you need to work through the frustration to get to the right answer.

We dismissed the proposed “legislative referral process” as too complicated. All I want for Christmas is this:

  • The board needs to know what committees are working on – we’re solving this with simple status reports
  • The board needs to know what committees are planning to work on next – we’re also solving this with simple status reports
  • The board gets an opportunity to place things on a committee’s agenda, with a majority vote – we’re doing this with a simple agenda item on the Committee of the Whole. The process is super simple: ask to add the topic to the agenda, show up, talk about it, vote on it, if it passes it gets added.

Is that too much to ask for Christmas? I’m asking for more collaboration and less dictatorial power as President. I can just unilaterally do this, but I don’t want that any more than I want each committee chair unilaterally deciding what’s important. Staff time, board member time, and operating expense are finite; we should spend all of it wisely.

Christmas gift

Employee survey results – this originated with employee survey results that identified the board as the biggest problem in the village. We had lots of discussion that ended with “we should talk to people more.” If you are an employee reading this, you are also welcome to call any of us at any time. I will explain anything we are doing, and give you my view of village challenges we need to solve. I am open to different perspectives and always more than willing to change my mind with new information. Don’t let 3rd hand information cause angst. Call, email, send an anonymous letter to my house, whatever. I won’t even make you look at spreadsheets if that’s not your thing. Ok, maybe just one spreadsheet.

Waters Edge FYI
#

There is a meeting today about Waters Edge, Wed, Nov 18 at 4pm. It is at the Siena Center, just south of the Waters Edge property. Address is 5637 Erie St. Proceed to the Chapel Entrance. We are meeting in the Administration Conference Room. The main part of the meeting is brainstorming and prioritizing ideas. The meeting is open to the public and we welcome your attendance.

December board meeting schedule
#

There will only be one village board meeting in December and it will be on Tue, December 15th.

Then starting in January, we’re changing back to 2nd and 4th Tuesday of every month. As always, visit the village website for details.