2 hours and a few minutes, 2 very substantive topics: Hagemann Rd and the 2027 Budget.
Hagemann Rd #
Being super brief here, we’re still trying hard to find an adequate compromise that protects all property owners, the residents on Hagemann Rd and the property owner that has requested a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) to build a self-storage facility behind the homes on Frontage Rd. This is by far the most difficult issue that we’ve had to navigate since I began as President. I’m sure we’re frustrating everyone with the time it is taking and the stress it is causing, but our intentions are pure.
Budget #
It passed 5-2, with the 2 dissenting votes objecting to the removal of the $500K splash pad. The Oct 6th board meeting recap goes into detail on that debate. Have a read if you aren’t familiar with the debate.
Now that the budget is passed, I’d like to offer an opinion on the state of finances for the village, prefacing with I’m learning the numbers as fast as I can, which I think is pretty fast, and the picture is getting clearer for me. I’m sure I have a lot still to learn, some of which will be good, and some likely to be eyebrow-raising. Spending decisions should always be made with firsthand and deep knowledge. Trusting is fine. Verifying is better. I’ll happily vote for discretionary expenses if the cost/benefit is good and if I’m confident we are in a position of financial strength to support the expense over its lifetime.
No one should worry that we’re about to fall off a cliff. Whatever was behind those hyperbolic statements back in June was completely unfounded. Sure we have problems to solve, but I see no cliff. I see a standard set of tough budget decisions every organization has to make every year.
Second, let’s talk about public safety staff since I was pressed to “tell them how many staff we’ll have to cut” when we rejected the TID6 tax reimbursement request. This year, the budget says we’re cutting exactly 0 positions, and the thought never crossed our minds. Now for some practical realities of municipal budgeting in this state. The state has a program that provides us $600K per year as long as we maintain our public safety staff levels. So think about the ramifications of that. If we cut 1 person with a cost of $100K, we’d need to cut 6 more with a cost of $100K to get a net $100K benefit to the budget. Translation: that is the absolute last lever we would ever pull.
Can disaster happen? Sure. Are we anywhere near that level of desperation. No. Was suggesting we were, publicly in a board meeting, irresponsible? In my opinion, yes.
I have a list of problems we need to solve before reaching confidence in our finances. Some are past mistakes we need to fix. Some are just visibility to data that lets us forecast better. Here are the biggies:
-
Net new construction data – this might be the most important number we have in the budget every year and right now we don’t know what it will be until August of the year following the construction. Fiscal cliff projections were based on growth projections of 0.4% per year and 2025’s growth was 1.753%. We have to have better data to base future forecasts on, and we should have a more accurate prior year number well before August.
-
TID forecasts have to improve. When a TID’s expenses are greater than its revenue in a year, we pay for that from reserves. Our budgeted amounts for TID 4 deficits are: 2025 - $2.1M, 2026 - $2.3M, 2027 - $1.9M. The most recent formal TID project plan we review annually shows these numbers: 2025 - positive $1.5M, 2026 - $338K deficit, and 2027 - $980K deficit. The formal TID project plan shows the TID turning positive on annual revenue minus expense in 2037, which isn’t soon. So can you see the concern here? If we are actually burning $2M per year, then in three years, our reserves are exhausted and we have a big problem. So this one’s simple: what is the realistic but conservative forecast? We have to know. I don’t see how we can ever make good decisions financially if our single largest financial commitment is like a random number generator.
-
We need a plan for Waters Edge. We’re actively working on that now and the financial ramifications of it should become clear soon.
-
TID 6 has an interesting problem to it. The boundaries are drawn like a gerrymandered Congressional district, meaning it includes a lot of property we don’t plan to develop but that we needed to include to make the TID boundary contiguous. For 20 years, all increases in property taxes from all properties within those boundaries will not be available to the general fund. They can only go towards TID 6 expenses. Does this create any general fund stress over the life of the TID? Maybe it’s a small enough number to not make a difference, but let’s calculate it.
-
We need a goal and plan for our debt levels. We’ve taken a step with 2027’s budget to stop the debt from growing. Now it’s time to put us on a path to reducing it. Debt should not be an escape valve. It should be a tool to pay for large capital expenses.
If we can get all those items resolved, we can be confident of our financial position. Maybe we’ll be confident we have problems. Maybe that we are fine. But we’ll know, and we’ll know what needs work. In the meantime, it’s not responsible to spend large sums on discretionary items. I hope you all agree, even if you might not like that desirable items are getting deferred. And just know that it’s the plan to resolve all those items as soon as possible. We should have a sense of urgency since it’s someone else’s money (yours) we’re spending.